Boveda Test

gio164
gio164 Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 180
in General Discussion
Here's a video that Boveda made comparing Boveda, Heartfelt, Xikar and Dr. RH. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WPqKLkBLFU&feature=player_embedded

Comments

  • Rain
    Rain Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 8,761
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WPqKLkBLFU
  • Martel
    Martel Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 2,423
    I'd like to see someone do this independently. Color me suspicious.
  • ddubridge
    ddubridge Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 3,949
    Kitty Litter for life...I've never been so stabil
  • Roberto99
    Roberto99 Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 1,077
    They do a comparison test without describing the testing procedures. What'd they do, soak the beads in water before putting them in the container?
  • jfaciane
    jfaciane Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 242
    Martel:
    I'd like to see someone do this independently. Color me suspicious.
    Me too. Of course you can make a test go the way you want when comparing your product to others. By the way, my heartfelt beads never gave off 100% humidity according to my digital hygrometer that records highs and lows until reset. LIARS!!!
  • reggie713
    reggie713 Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 2,018
    jfaciane:
    Martel:
    I'd like to see someone do this independently. Color me suspicious.
    Me too. Of course you can make a test go the way you want when comparing your product to others. By the way, my heartfelt beads never gave off 100% humidity according to my digital hygrometer that records highs and lows until reset. LIARS!!!
    i second this, my heartfelt beads have never been over 75
  • ehehat
    ehehat Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 1,534
    ddubridge:
    Kitty Litter for life...I've never been so stabil
    x 1000
  • reggie713
    reggie713 Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 2,018
    ehehat:
    ddubridge:
    Kitty Litter for life...I've never been so stabil
    x 1000
    i have kitty litter in my cooler, hasnt moved a lick
  • catfishbluezz
    catfishbluezz Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 6,993
    reggie713:
    ehehat:
    ddubridge:
    Kitty Litter for life...I've never been so stabil
    x 1000
    i have kitty litter in my cooler, hasnt moved a lick
    yup... Learned a new microwaving trick as well, gonna try it here soon and post results. Apparently you can nuke them to dry them out and they are even better.
  • catfishbluezz
    catfishbluezz Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 6,993
    I could probably recreate this test as well. I'm very surprised at how they did it in Tupperware, not a humi with cedar. I may just do it sometime for the hell of it, as I have boveda, dr rh, drymistat, heartfelt, and kl.
  • Demosthenes
    Demosthenes Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 5
    I'd like to hear what happens if you do try to recreate this, Cat. I'm very skeptical about these results. I've never heard of anyone having 100% RH in a humidor.

    P.S. After seasoning like you described and a good bit of KL I'm sitting pretty at 70% RH and stable as can be. That in itself discourages me from using any other products.
  • Rain
    Rain Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 8,761
    PS - We've spoken on this before.

Categories