In your opinion, which cigar has that "classic" cigar taste?

bacon.jay · January 2010

Hawk55 · January 2010

Hey J...I will have to clear the smoke in my head...from the cigars I've smoked there before I can give a halfway intelligible response to that....(man what a picture that statement made...in my head) LOL

lilwing88 · January 2010

I'd have to go with a R y J 1875 Bully or an H. Upmann Vintage Camaroon. They're both made in and out of Cuba.

dennisking · January 2010

Padilla Habano churchill gets my vote. The right smell, spice, and just overall presence.

fla-gypsy · January 2010

I love the Padilla Habano but no one cigar can speak for all. The cigar that first screamed high quality to me was the Montecristo #2.

dennisking · January 2010

fla-gypsy:
I love the Padilla Habano but no one cigar can speak for all. The cigar that first screamed high quality to me was the Montecristo #2.

That's funny because that was the first cigar I smoked and thought, DAMN, this is a great stick

camgfs · January 2010

madurofan · January 2010

ejenne87 · January 2010

zoom6zoom · January 2010

ejenne87 · January 2010

dennisking · January 2010

I'll third the vote for a 5Vegas Classic. the right balance with the right amount of everything

BStayer · January 2010

mmmmmm...5 Vegas Classic...a very wonderful smoke!

kuzi16 · January 2010

i always thought the montecristo platinum was the classic cigar taste. iduno. never really smoked a "classic" cigar.

bigharpoon · January 2010

Classic makes me think of Partagas.

nudie · January 2010

looks like this is gonna be a *vote* thread... one vote per member... ill tally them up and update totals daily... winner announced next friday

zoom6zoom · January 2010

BStayer:
mmmmmm...5 Vegas Classic...a very wonderful smoke!

and today's daily deal... stock up!

In your opinion, which cigar has that &quot;classic&quot; cigar taste?

Comments

In your opinion, which cigar has that "classic" cigar taste?