Top 10 Mild Cigars According to YOU

Renaissance_Man

So I decided to tabulate in a spreadsheets the feedback you guys gave in my other thread about mild cigars. Here is the Top 10, followed by number of votes for each. I must say I was not surprised at all with the Top 3 and the big difference between them and the rest. Here is the list - http://wbfiller.com/top-10-mild-cigars-according-to-cigar-com-forum-members/

sightunseen

Nooooo Cabaiguan didn't place.

xmacro

I'd put the Monty White first and the Perdomo 10th Anniv above the RP Connie, but otherwise a pretty good list - definitely agree every cigar on that list is a really good mild smoke.

phobicsquirrel

I like the monte whites, they would be my top one I guess.

stephen_hannibal

Hayblet

Renaissance_Man

Yeah, all votes bellow third spot are really equal so it's kind of "Top 3 plus lots of 4th places" list ... I however don't really get it how the nub conny is number 2... I should give it another try - first one I had didn't impress me much...

phobicsquirrel

j0z3r

Hayblet

I'm really surprised I'm the only one who suggested Ccom's purple label

kuzi16

stephen_hannibal

kuzi16

Renaissance_Man

Poker Slob

Thanks for taking the time to do this. This is very interesting indeed.

kuzi16

fla-gypsy

I tried a Padilla Hybrid this morning at 0530 and thought it was pretty good. I am not a fan of mild and not sure this is really a mild but it's as close as I am going to get.

Heavy

I think i mentioned the purple in that thread (I think i did anyway). I've only had a couple and it's been a while ago, but I remember being surprised at how much I liked it.

Heavy

Hayblet:

I'm really surprised I'm the only one who suggested Ccom's purple label

^^above post was referring this this

Renaissance_Man

Heavy:

I think i mentioned the purple in that thread (I think i did anyway). I've only had a couple and it's been a while ago, but I remember being surprised at how much I liked it.

Yeah - I think yours was the only vote for this that I saw in the other thread... I have never tried any other labels but the Brazilian. If they come close to quality however - I'll def. give the purple a try...

MrBuhl

phobicsquirrel:

I like the monte whites, they would be my top one I guess.

+3 on the Monte Whites for number one -

MrMoke

Poker Slob:

Thanks for taking the time to do this. This is very interesting indeed.

I'll 2nd that, it is very interesting!! thasnxs for putting iit together

Renaissance_Man

MrMoke:

Poker Slob:

Thanks for taking the time to do this. This is very interesting indeed.

I'll 2nd that, it is very interesting!! thasnxs for putting iit together

Not much done here boys! I wanted to get an idea for myself - its why I asked in the forum. This is simply taking 10 minutes to sort through the responses and putting it online. I must say - if you ever need a list like this or need an answer on what to try - Cigar.com forum members have been the most helpful and responsive BOTLs I have ever seen/met! Cheers!