WOW this thing seem to have gotten all Crazy! Some guys have Sticks laying in their Humis they Paid Nothing for or got In Some deal Really CHEAP... Other may have to Pick up a Couple of EXPENSIVE Sticks to Feel worthy of what they want to take, I know Cigar Prices are all over the Map,What Some think is their top ten is Far from Others. Maybe this thread should Be TOP TEN PRICIEST CIGARS no Matter if they are any good! ALL GUHRKAS are Over Priced to me and I Personally I think Most of them are Horrible, All that Being Said It will be interesting to see What Transpires and the Posting of the List of who gets what and leaves what Is a Really Bad Idea. Keep it Between the BOTL in the Pass Only.
WOW this thing seem to have gotten all Crazy! Some guys have Sticks laying in their Humis they Paid Nothing for or got In Some deal Really CHEAP... Other may have to Pick up a Couple of EXPENSIVE Sticks to Feel worthy of what they want to take, I know Cigar Prices are all over the Map,What Some think is their top ten is Far from Others. Maybe this thread should Be TOP TEN PRICIEST CIGARS no Matter if they are any good! ALL GUHRKAS are Over Priced to me and I Personally I think Most of them are Horrible, All that Being Said It will be interesting to see What Transpires and the Posting of the List of who gets what and leaves what Is a Really Bad Idea. Keep it Between the BOTL in the Pass Only.
Why is posting takes and what you leave a bad idea? You said yourself prices are all over the board and some BOTL think Gurkha's are the best out there. This will allow people to see what was in the pass, what got left and what got taken out. It can serve to see some peoples choices which could help with future passes to an individual. The list will also help if there are any problems. I can think of these and maybe other reasons why this is a good idea. I can't think of any reason why it is a bad one?
I think the pass is worth a shot. I have a idea what the "going" price of a stick is, wether I got it on a trade or not. If we all stick to the post up your in's and out's, i think it will police itself. May I add that if a noob, like myself, makes a mistake........ dont everyone jump his sh!t, Im sure there will be ways to work everything out. Im looking forword to this one!
I say all sticks taken out of the bag should be listed, as well as all sticks put in the bag. Initial 10 sticks need not be listed, just what is removed and replaced by each BOTL. Keeps people honest and fair, but even moreso it allows all of us to see what is going around and what treats are being passed.
I think we are making this a bit complicated list everthing use good judgement. If every one has a problem with the stick trade we could A find a person to make all calls like you would have to pm your choices to a moderater who makes all the decisions. B just take things the way they are or pull your name off the list
I think we are making this a bit complicated list everthing use good judgement. If every one has a problem with the stick trade we could A find a person to make all calls like you would have to pm your choices to a moderater who makes all the decisions. B just take things the way they are or pull your name off the list
Listing outs and takes has been done several times (at least) in the past. It works, is NOT complicated and it tends to keep everything on the up and up. Having to ask a third party if the sticks I am sending are worthy... now that's complicated. This is a non issue boy's.
I think Ozzie was going for the not posting the takes and puts on the forum but keeping the list. The purpose of posting is so people who already had the pass still have an idea of what everyone likes. That being said once it finishes the final list can be PM'd to all who participated to avoid being open to all but is still available to all who take part.
I think Ozzie was going for the not posting the takes and puts on the forum but keeping the list. The purpose of posting is so people who already had the pass still have an idea of what everyone likes. That being said once it finishes the final list can be PM'd to all who participated to avoid being open to all but is still available to all who take part.
I have no problem with how you run this pass Sirfoster. It is YOUR pass, you decide. I don't understand why we would want to keep it private to participating members only but, whatever you decide as the PassMaster will be the way it goes.
I think we are making this a bit complicated list everthing use good judgement. If every one has a problem with the stick trade we could A find a person to make all calls like you would have to pm your choices to a moderater who makes all the decisions. B just take things the way they are or pull your name off the list
Listing outs and takes has been done several times (at least) in the past. It works, is NOT complicated and it tends to keep everything on the up and up. Having to ask a third party if the sticks I am sending are worthy... now that's complicated. This is a non issue boy's.
No man I with you on this my post must of been misunderstood I was saying how do we find out what is a good trade for whAT is getting complicated I say use good judgemet that was my point if you dont know ask.
Lol this is interesting. Me personally i think that this Community is based on trust, Thats why were able to make blind trade with one another no? Keep in mind that this is a TOP 10 not TOP 10 most expensive. I have a Gurkhas on my Top 10 but will not be putting it in for this game. I think everyone should know what not to trade out. If someone is willing to get a list of what everyone is taking and sending go for it.
poor kid is 16 months and getting all 4 2yr molars along with 2 other teeth and they are treating him for an eye infection now. Have to go back next month looking like he might need tubes put in.
poor kid is 16 months and getting all 4 2yr molars along with 2 other teeth and they are treating him for an eye infection now. Have to go back next month looking like he might need tubes put in.
The hardest things in my life were always the feelings of helplessness when one of the kids were sick or got hurt. I look back now that my kids are now adults and wonder how someone as high strung as myself made it through without having a breakdown. I feel for you bro'.
WOW this thing seem to have gotten all Crazy! Some guys have Sticks laying in their Humis they Paid Nothing for or got In Some deal Really CHEAP... Other may have to Pick up a Couple of EXPENSIVE Sticks to Feel worthy of what they want to take, I know Cigar Prices are all over the Map,What Some think is their top ten is Far from Others. Maybe this thread should Be TOP TEN PRICIEST CIGARS no Matter if they are any good! ALL GUHRKAS are Over Priced to me and I Personally I think Most of them are Horrible, All that Being Said It will be interesting to see What Transpires and the Posting of the List of who gets what and leaves what Is a Really Bad Idea. Keep it Between the BOTL in the Pass Only.
Why is posting takes and what you leave a bad idea? You said yourself prices are all over the board and some BOTL think Gurkha's are the best out there. This will allow people to see what was in the pass, what got left and what got taken out. It can serve to see some peoples choices which could help with future passes to an individual. The list will also help if there are any problems. I can think of these and maybe other reasons why this is a good idea. I can't think of any reason why it is a bad one?
For what it's worth, I don't have a problem posting what I took and put in...I would be kinda curious also to see what's in the pass as it travels. I for one think it's a good idea.
WOW this thing seem to have gotten all Crazy! Some guys have Sticks laying in their Humis they Paid Nothing for or got In Some deal Really CHEAP... Other may have to Pick up a Couple of EXPENSIVE Sticks to Feel worthy of what they want to take, I know Cigar Prices are all over the Map,What Some think is their top ten is Far from Others. Maybe this thread should Be TOP TEN PRICIEST CIGARS no Matter if they are any good! ALL GUHRKAS are Over Priced to me and I Personally I think Most of them are Horrible, All that Being Said It will be interesting to see What Transpires and the Posting of the List of who gets what and leaves what Is a Really Bad Idea. Keep it Between the BOTL in the Pass Only.
Why is posting takes and what you leave a bad idea? You said yourself prices are all over the board and some BOTL think Gurkha's are the best out there. This will allow people to see what was in the pass, what got left and what got taken out. It can serve to see some peoples choices which could help with future passes to an individual. The list will also help if there are any problems. I can think of these and maybe other reasons why this is a good idea. I can't think of any reason why it is a bad one?
For what it's worth, I don't have a problem posting what I took and put in...I would be kinda curious also to see what's in the pass as it travels. I for one think it's a good idea.
+1 Krieg....I am 2nd and I think I will post whats in it when I get it and when it leaves for everyone. People can do it if they want I guess, but for the sake of interest I want to know as well.
WOW this thing seem to have gotten all Crazy! Some guys have Sticks laying in their Humis they Paid Nothing for or got In Some deal Really CHEAP... Other may have to Pick up a Couple of EXPENSIVE Sticks to Feel worthy of what they want to take, I know Cigar Prices are all over the Map,What Some think is their top ten is Far from Others. Maybe this thread should Be TOP TEN PRICIEST CIGARS no Matter if they are any good! ALL GUHRKAS are Over Priced to me and I Personally I think Most of them are Horrible, All that Being Said It will be interesting to see What Transpires and the Posting of the List of who gets what and leaves what Is a Really Bad Idea. Keep it Between the BOTL in the Pass Only.
Why is posting takes and what you leave a bad idea? You said yourself prices are all over the board and some BOTL think Gurkha's are the best out there. This will allow people to see what was in the pass, what got left and what got taken out. It can serve to see some peoples choices which could help with future passes to an individual. The list will also help if there are any problems. I can think of these and maybe other reasons why this is a good idea. I can't think of any reason why it is a bad one?
For what it's worth, I don't have a problem posting what I took and put in...I would be kinda curious also to see what's in the pass as it travels. I for one think it's a good idea.
+1 Krieg....I am 2nd and I think I will post whats in it when I get it and when it leaves for everyone. People can do it if they want I guess, but for the sake of interest I want to know as well.
+2 Ill be doing the same. But just to find out what people think about my top 10. They are not the most expensive sticks out there but they are some hard to find ones. For example. I will most likely be throwing in a few of my well aged (3 years +) wich in my mind is better than some of my FFOX. But how do we set a msrp for it?
Comments