Click this link Click or go to page 3 for the update.
I'm looking for suggestions on trays/dividers. Thanks in advance for your input!
So I finally had some free time now that the holidays are over and got the chance to finish sanding and putting together the new coolidor!
Thanks to everyone who chimed in on how I should seal the slight gap around the lid.
Per your suggestions, I went with a 1/4" rubber/foam weather stripping with an adhesive backing and it's working great.
I found that the hardest part of this project was sanding the SC boards down so that everything fit nice and snug....since the interior of the cooler was not perfectly square to begin with, it was impossible to take exact measurements and cut the boards square....so needless to say, quite a bit of hand sanding was needed to make everything fit.
Below are a few pictures of the (almost) final product....I just need to season it, add some beads+hygrometer, then fill it up with cigars.
(Also somewhere down the road, I want to do a design with old cigar bands and either attach that to the lid or to the front of it. Look close and you can see a few small screw holes where there was a horseshoe and star attached on the original cooler.)

