hey bro, have you tried any of the Acid line by Drew Estate? They are infused cigars, some of them like the Kuba Kuba have (what I think) is some sweetness but not like a swisher would be. ... a little more subtle.
I swear I'm not making this suggestion just because it was my Expert Pick this month! I had a customer call me a few months ago with the same problem. I gave him a CAO Cameroon to try, and he absolutely loved it!
Assuming you'd like to have non-infused cigars, I've found that the 5 Vegas Gold Maduro has a natural chocolate-y sweetness with little to no pepperiness.
Tatuaje's may have some spice, but they all seem to have a characteristic sweetness to them. If you can get your hands on a Wolfman, it just may blow your mind.
Comments