1 for 1 and it is a strange offer. (Edited)

jd50ae

Back on.....read further down. Edited.

WaltBasil

jd50ae:

They will be sent un-banded and safely numbered. Let them rest for a week or two and then smoke them at your own pace. Pick out the 1 you like the most and I will tell you what all 3 are. Of course you do the same.

Hope this isn't too off the wall.....

Just checked my humidor and I can do 3 trades.

I think "off the wall" would be something like "tell me what you think and I'll tell you where they've been..."

jd50ae

back and it is now a 1 for 1....read further down

WaltBasil

No. I thought it was cool. Like a blind taste test. But sounds like work. ;-)

MVW67

Not a dumb idea, kinda cool. Think we had one thread around for one stick. Three could be hard, though.:-) :-)

jd50ae

The reason I deleted it is because after so many hits no one replied and thought it best to remove it

I think I might re-introduce it with, as suggested, 1 cigar.

LiquidChaos66

I think it's an awesome idea! Open it back up!!!! That would be super fun! Not knowing what your are smoking or what to really expect....

jd50ae

LiquidChaos66:

I think it's an awesome idea! Open it back up!!!! That would be super fun! Not knowing what your are smoking or what to really expect....

All righty then.

1 for 1. No bands or ID. Exchange and smoke when you are ready. Give and honest opinion about the cigar..like, dislike or indifferent...and why. And then, and only then, tell each other what it is.

The original post was 3 for 3 and I could do 3 exchanges, but (quick math (and no help from allsmokedup)) and now I am open to 9 exchanges.

Who has game..? PM me with your addy if you are in.

LiquidChaos66

jd50ae:

LiquidChaos66:

I think it's an awesome idea! Open it back up!!!! That would be super fun! Not knowing what your are smoking or what to really expect....

All righty then.

1 for 1. No bands or ID. Exchange and smoke when you are ready. Give and honest opinion about the cigar..like, dislike or indifferent...and why. And then, and only then, tell each other what it is.

The original post was 3 for 3 and I could do 3 exchanges, but (quick math (and no help from allsmokedup)) and now I am open to 9 exchanges.

Who has game..? PM me with your addy if you are in.

I'm currently on the broke side of the month. I would totally be up for this in January! Would you still be up for it next month???

jd50ae

LiquidChaos66:

jd50ae:

LiquidChaos66:

I think it's an awesome idea! Open it back up!!!! That would be super fun! Not knowing what your are smoking or what to really expect....

All righty then.

1 for 1. No bands or ID. Exchange and smoke when you are ready. Give and honest opinion about the cigar..like, dislike or indifferent...and why. And then, and only then, tell each other what it is.

The original post was 3 for 3 and I could do 3 exchanges, but (quick math (and no help from allsmokedup)) and now I am open to 9 exchanges.

Who has game..? PM me with your addy if you are in.

I'm currently on the broke side of the month. I would totally be up for this in January! Would you still be up for it next month???

So am I. I have however, put 1 aside with your name (ID) on it.

LiquidChaos66

Awesome! I have just the stick for you as well!

Jetmech_63

I started a game a ways back called "mystery stick", it was a slight spin on Camachos Black Band project. It was similar to PIF in that i send you 3 cigars, no bands, labeled a,b and c. You smoke them within a week, post thoughts and guesses and i reveal what they were, you then do the same for someone else. It was cool because it removes and assumption or pretention about the cigar and focuses on flavor. We had people hating opus X and loving perdomo seconds...it was fun but the thread went cold earlier this year.

jd50ae

Jetmech_63:

I started a game a ways back called "mystery stick", it was a slight spin on Camachos Black Band project. It was similar to PIF in that i send you 3 cigars, no bands, labeled a,b and c. You smoke them within a week, post thoughts and guesses and i reveal what they were, you then do the same for someone else. It was cool because it removes and assumption or pretention about the cigar and focuses on flavor. We had people hating opus X and loving perdomo seconds...it was fun but the thread went cold earlier this year.

I looked for a post because I could not believe a newb would be the first to think of it. Hope it finds some success again.

WaltBasil

I'll be your huckleberry.