If you could only have one cigar, what would it be?

Goldy

If you could have one cigar, regardless of price, what would it be?

Matt Marvel

Only one? Hmm.. I have no idea. Padron '64.

mustluvcigars

tough to just choose one: Padilla 1932

betasynn

Camacho 8/11 or 5 Vegas Cask Strength II. Can't decide.

MAJORdorMo

Carlos Torano Signature

gmill880

TatuajeVI

My favorite cigar I have ever had is probably the Camacho Pre Embargo. I've had three of the original five I bought and about passed out due to ecstasy during each of the three. Had a similar reaction to a CAO Vision Prana that had been aging two years.

Luko

If I only get one more before I die, then I have to know I'm gonna like it. I don't want to take chances on a HMR or something like that. In the year or so I'm been enjoying cigars, the three most enjoyable experiences I've had involved a DP Cuban Classic, a RP vintage 1992 and an RP Decade (and subsequent have only reaffirmed my feelings) so I guess at this point I would pick one of those.

bigbgballz

R&J Reserva Real No2 Belicoso

Lasabar

I don't really have a hands down drag out favorite, but if I had to say the cigar that I've enjoyed the most so far would be Romeo y Julieta Habana Reserve or Nica Libre (Haven't smoked my fair share yet, but these things are G-O-O-D)

ejenne87

Matt Marvel:

Only one? Hmm.. I have no idea. Padron '64.

I def. agree with that. It's my favorite so far, always the exact same as the first time I had one.

Grahamcracker

Hays

If I could have only one cigar for the rest of my life, it'd be the Rocky Patel Vintage 1990... Those just call my name every time I walk into the humidor. If I could pick just one to try out of all the possible choices, it'd have to be an aged HMR - if I'm not paying for it, why the heck not?

j0z3r

Ok, my Desert Island cigar would be the La Flor Dominicana Cameroon Cabinet #1. It would be a very close though between that and the Padron '64 toro in the habano wrapper.

vankleekkw

Renaissance_Man

RP Decade Torpedo....

cabinetmaker

I'm not sure what it would be...Padilla 1932, maybe GOF Don Carlos...

laker1963

These Filthy Hands

JZ

Padron 64

kaspera79

The best cigar I have ever had was a Partagas Serie D #4 That would be my forever cigar.

j0z3r

That's a killer cigar Kas.

Lasabar

kaspera79

YankeeMan

Monticristo Classic.

24footjet

Padron 1964

laker1963

kaspera79

Hey Laker.. Reply sent.

laker1963

kaspera79:

Hey Laker.. Reply sent.

Got it Kas. Consider it done. I'll be in touch.

rad1964

Goldy

Cool, I wanted some ideas of great cigars I need to try and it looks like I have a great selection. I think my cigar would be either a R&J Viejo or a PE comacho.