Andrew Luck

Rain

What does that make...7 INTs in two playoff games? I have no idea why people think he is even a marginal QB. RG III and Russell Wilson are wayyyyyyyyy superior.7!!! Elite QBs post roughly that for an entire season.

Jetmech_63

Rg3....and I'm a skins fan, is broke ***. He just needs to realize that

Martel

webmost

Nick Foles threw TWO picks ALL YEAR.

YankeeMan

New Boots

Rain

SleevePlz

YankeeMan

raisindot

Martel

webmost:

Nick Foles threw TWO picks ALL YEAR.

Luck threw 9 before the playoffs. Half what he had last year. Both Mannings have only thrown that few one season in their careers. Add in leadership, running ability, size and toughness, and incredible smarts and work ethic. He would be #1 this year, for sure. Or most years. Oh, and one of the worst O-lines in the NFL for both run and pass blocking.

Vulchor

Dont understand ANY Luck bashing at all. Bad decisions? Sometimes. Young and needing to "learn to win"? Sure. However, the talent plus the upside plus the sheer work ethic and apporach to the game makes him the next Brady or Manning in my mind.

blutattoo

Rain

So when he just slings it in to double coverage and someone catches it, he's "Showing of his talent" or "being a gunslinger."Yet when he fails...he's "learning to win." Learning to win by losing? Ok........I guess Romo is the master if winning then.Then again, the Colts did pick Luck over Manning, which is a bust as of right now...we'll look back in 10 years. They also traded for T Rich....so, yeah.Oh, Jason, I was more speaking about the "He's done more in two years then a lot of people in ten." Like....what?

Vulchor

Luck has the same number of championships as Manning since they let him go-----and only 1 more overall for that matter....not that I am necessarily comparing the two. Also, Luck will be around much longer than Manning and the team Manning would have in Indy still wouldnt have been good enough to wit it all without Wayne, and with a questionable line to protect him. So, both sides seem to have won in that one.

blutattoo

Well he's done more than Romo, that I can be sure of. They have the same number of playoff wins for their career. But in general you're right he is not there yet, but his upside is way higher than most. I'd love to have him on the Cowboys. I'm reasonable certain he can win with less. There have been a lot of great qb's that have thrown a lot of interceptions. Favre, Unitas, Elway, Marino all come to mind. All high risk, high reward qb's

No_one21

I just want to point out that the horrid excuse for a man Eli Manning (I'm very biased as a Pats fan lol) threw 27 int this season. 27!!!!! And he's won a few lucky super bowls along with other stats I'm sure are better than horrible. Luck has a promising future I think.

JMartinez10

webmost