Top 5 Sticks In Your Humidor?

Wmstephen96

I only JUST started out, but my top 5 (not in order) are: Cohiba black, Cohiba extra vigiroso, and the Edicion Limitada 2014 series Habana Cohiba, Romeo, and Monte cubans

What about you?
EDIT: somehow there seems to be a lot of confusion my the meaning of "top", SO..... If you could only choose five of the sticks in your humidor for the rest of your life, which five would they be?

Amos Umwhat

Sounds like you're off to a good start. I guess mine, as of now, MOW Armada, Opus X, Reconquista, ISOM Montecristo, 5-Vegas 10 year Limitada.

Martel

Ashton VSG
LFD DL
Oliva Serie V Melanio
Opus X Lost City
Padron 1964 Anni

Those are in no particular order. I almost dropped the Padron in favor of some others, but I'm guaranteed it will taste like I expect while the others sometimes surprise me. The Opus makes it based on anticipation; I've never had the Lost City. This one was a gift and I'm getting some age on it before I smoke it. There are other smokes that could supplant several of these, easily, but they're not currently in the humi.

pelirrojo

Tough question, but a fun one to think about.

AF Anejo Shark
DPG Blue (old before foot band, nasty yellow cellophane)
Tatuaje TAA 2011
LGC Inmensos (cc, unknown year)
Viaje Zombie 2012

I actually haven't smoked any of these. They could all be terrible, but I doubt it very seriously haha.

jgibv

Wmstephen96:

I only JUST started out, but my top 5 (not in order) are: Cohiba black, Cohiba extra vigiroso, and the Edicion Limitada 2014 series Habana Cohiba, Romeo, and Monte cubans What about you?

first off, welcome to the forum!

second .... be sure to check out the "Newbie Welcoming Thread" and introduce yourself --- here: http://www.cigar.com/cs/forums/thread/3027.aspx
and also the "Newbs to the Forums Please READ!!!!" thread. Lots of good info there and answers to many FAQ that pop up --- here: http://www.cigar.com/cs/forums/25/437201/ShowThread.aspx#437201




also, are we talking top 5 favorites?
(or top 5 rare/hard to find?)

if favs --- right now it'd probably be:

1) mow virtue & angelenos (tie)
3) san miguel
4) camacho pe
5) illusione mj12 nat

(but this list is ever changing. ask me again next month and i'd bet you my list is different or at least in a different order)

honorable mention: avo dominant 13th.

and i can think of about 3 other current favs but i'm all out of them at the moment.

rwheelwright

Tough question. For me:
Opus X Forbidden X 2006
Opus X Maduro
Opus X Lost City
Destino Al Siglo
2005 GoF Don Carlos


Close runners up are:
1 Single Anejo #55 from 2008
A really Old Don Carlos I got from Joe
Padron 1926 80th Maduro
ISOM Cohiba
2004 GoF Carlito
A full Original Release box of Armada

avengethis

Davidoff Year of the Sheep
Opus X XXX from 1999
Cohiba Behike 54
Oliva Master Blends 2
DPG Series JJ from 2006

twistedstem

kinda makes you think for a minute. Right now my top 5 smokes are My FatherLaBijou[just had my first one aroundhalloween) San Cristobel (anyone of them!) AVO (tan band) Sancho Panza maduro and my favorite go to yard gar factory 59 throwout

Chuck N

Thats a tough question? Im torn between the ones I really love smoking and the ones I have for collecting and aging. I guess my most treasured are some old Opus X and htf Tats.

Rain

Forum blend. 'nuff said

ddubridge

Rain:

Forum blend. 'nuff said

Beat me to it. I've got five of them.

LiquidChaos66

Ooooooh I like this thread!

Cohiba Red Dot
Undercrown
Ave Maria
Perdomo 10th Anniversary Champagne
MOW Virtue

So many tastys lol

Puff_Dougie

Cool thread.

Crowned Heads Mason Dixon (North & South)
Kristoff Maduro Lancero
Leaf by Oscar (Maduro & Sumatra)
RP Edge Candela
Ave Maria Imaculata

Wmstephen96

Rain:

Forum blend. 'nuff said

which label opus? Ive been hearing alot of opus, especially lost city

Rain

Wmstephen96

Chuck N:

Thats a tough question? Im torn between the ones I really love smoking and the ones I have for collecting and aging. I guess my most treasured are some old Opus X and htf Tats.

which opus? ive heard alot about the lost city especially

Hays

Wmstephen96:

I only JUST started out, but my top 5 (not in order) are: Cohiba black, Cohiba extra vigiroso, and the Edicion Limitada 2014 series Habana Cohiba, Romeo, and Monte cubans What about you?

Welcome to the forums! At the moment my humidor has less than 5, so I don't have much to add to the thread, except this question: you sure about those Cubans, buddy? Habanos 2014 LE releases were a Cohiba, Partagas, and Bolivar (no LE Montes or Romeos in 2014). Not saying you're lying, just wondering whether the year is off or if you have fakes :-{

Wmstephen96

Rain:

My bad, wromg post!

Wmstephen96

Hays:

Wmstephen96:

I only JUST started out, but my top 5 (not in order) are: Cohiba black, Cohiba extra vigiroso, and the Edicion Limitada 2014 series Habana Cohiba, Romeo, and Monte cubans

What about you?

Welcome to the forums! At the moment my humidor has less than 5, so I don't have much to add to the thread, except this question: you sure about those Cubans, buddy? Habanos 2014 LE releases were a Cohiba, Partagas, and Bolivar (no LE Montes or Romeos in 2014). Not saying you're lying, just wondering whether the year is off or if you have fakes :-{

Id post a picture of all five of my 2014 cuban limiteds but i dont know how to post the picture

0patience

Davidoff Royal Robusto
Stradivarius de los Maestros Robusto Major
Partagas 150
Partagas 160
Don Carlos Edicion de Aniversario

A few of them were gifts from some great people and are my prized possessions.
The problem with that is finding the right occasion to smoke them.

thehilk

This thread scared me, I still feel like a newbie when it comes to cigars. Plus this can be taken many ways, what constitutes top? My favorites? My cherished? Most of the cigars I'd say are my tops, I haven't even smoked yet, lol. Been saving for a special occasion.

1. Cohiba Commador. Mrs. HILK bought a 3 pack for me when my son was born
2. 5 Vegas Miami. Originals got one from Mr. drew Dubridge and proceeded to get as many as possible
3. A. fuente Shark. Haven't tried yet but heard great things
4. The crowned heads 4 kicks
5. Nub cameroon all time favorite cigar

Runner ups
Gurkha red witch
Foundry wells
Camacho triple maduro

Echambers

Wmstephen96:

Hays:

Wmstephen96:

I only JUST started out, but my top 5 (not in order) are: Cohiba black, Cohiba extra vigiroso, and the Edicion Limitada 2014 series Habana Cohiba, Romeo, and Monte cubans What about you?

Welcome to the forums! At the moment my humidor has less than 5, so I don't have much to add to the thread, except this question: you sure about those Cubans, buddy? Habanos 2014 LE releases were a Cohiba, Partagas, and Bolivar (no LE Montes or Romeos in 2014). Not saying you're lying, just wondering whether the year is off or if you have fakes :-{

Id post a picture of all five of my 2014 cuban limiteds but i dont know how to post the picture

Are these the ones that came in a glass front box?

CharlieHeis

Opus X Angel's Share
Opus X Lost City
Opus X Fuente Fuente
Fuente Anejo Shark
God of Fire Don Carlito 2009

Alternates: A few ISOMs (nothing top shelf)
I haven't smoked any of these before. Might have to change that soon.

Retircs1

Wmstephen96:

I only JUST started out, but my top 5 (not in order) are: Cohiba black, Cohiba extra vigiroso, and the Edicion Limitada 2014 series Habana Cohiba, Romeo, and Monte cubans What about you?

what do you mean top 5? is it what we consider top? or ones that having rating in the 90 +

kaspera79

Echambers:

Wmstephen96:

Hays:

Wmstephen96:

I only JUST started out, but my top 5 (not in order) are: Cohiba black, Cohiba extra vigiroso, and the Edicion Limitada 2014 series Habana Cohiba, Romeo, and Monte cubans What about you?

Welcome to the forums! At the moment my humidor has less than 5, so I don't have much to add to the thread, except this question: you sure about those Cubans, buddy? Habanos 2014 LE releases were a Cohiba, Partagas, and Bolivar (no LE Montes or Romeos in 2014). Not saying you're lying, just wondering whether the year is off or if you have fakes :-{

Id post a picture of all five of my 2014 cuban limiteds but i dont know how to post the picture

Are these the ones that came in a glass front box?

I hope the answer to that question is ... No.

Wmstephen96

Right. After you said they could be fake i inspected them and my monte's label looks poorly made. Possibly fakes. My granpa gottem for me. But Whatchya gunna do...

Wmstephen96

As in your most prized or favorites. My favorites are also my most prized

0patience

Favorite would infer that you like to smoke them regularly or at least more than once.

Prized would infer something you cherish, whether is be because someone special had gifted it to you or it is one that is so good that you would only smoke it on special occasions.

So, which is it?

90+ Irishman

Top 5 Most Cherished:

1. Hamlet Custom Roll shaggy foot torpedo
2. Partagas 155th Anniversary Salomon
3. OR Liga Privada T52 Flying Pig
4. Opus X Forbbidden X Lancero coffined 2007
5. Davidoff Year of the Sheep


Top 5 Favorite Smokes in My Humi:

1. Tatuaje Le Vérité 2008 Churchill
2. La Palina Goldie Laguito No 5
3. Bolivar Belicoso Finos (April 2011 release)
4. Zino Embassey Selection 2012
5. Tatuaje Monster Series Jason

jsnake

1. Viaje Daisy Cutter only have 1 after I smoked 1. Took me 4 years to find one and then another followed right after
2. Viaje Zombie Original Release. Back in the day I hunted these down and shared. After they were gone I thought what the hell was I thinking giving so many away. Now I have 1 again for a special day
3. Viaje Zombie Red 2014. 4. Viaje Skull & Bones Mystery Original Release
5. All of my other Viaje

You may wonder if I smoke anything other than Viaje and truth is not often anymore. I am sure I am missing out on great things but Viaje has never let me down. They are not all unicorn farts and rainbows but I have yet to smoke one I didn't like. A majority are amazing IMO. I often find myself in a debate when buying because I know Viaje can be hard to find so when I am thinking of another brand I often talk myself into buying whatever Viaje I can find.

Rhamlin

A couple Opus,s a few Padron 64,s and 26,s some Pepins blues and Cuban Classics and a couple My Fathers I have left.