Biggest Letdown

What's the one cigar that stands out, that you had high hopes for and it spit on you? Mine is a Padron 26. I had a 64 that was the best cigar I've ever had, and so I expected the world of the 26. It left me crying alone in the bathroom..

Find more posts tagged with

Comments

ShotgunJohn

I was let down when San Migel was dropped by AJ I thought that was a good medium blend. I think the biggest let down I had was with CAO OSA SOL, it just wasn't as good as I expected. Another stick that was just horrible was the Mark Twain churchill, I got through about 2 inches and had to toss it, it was acrid, and just nasty.

kuzi16

Rhamlin:
My biggest let down has been any ISOM that I have tried. Admittedly I've only had 5 but I always expected more out of them.

never walk into a cigar expecting things.

the biggest letdown for me has been Padron 1926. there is so much hype, and so many people that swear by them and then once lit up there wasnt anything special about the initial flavor and the aftertaste was longer and spicier and not as well refined as i had hoped. a cigar with such a reputation should be at least a good version of not my taste. i have smoked plenty of cigars that were not my taste but i can see why others love them (Davidoff Gran Cru, Tatuaje Cojonu 2009, 5 vegas Miami) but i dont get why this line gets the praise it does.

Vulchor

TONS of sticks for me....but ones that actually cost a price worth saying d@mnit about would be...Ashton ESG, Davidoff (pretty much any but their maduro), Greycliff Grand Cru, Avo La Trompeta, Pinolero, RP 15th Anniversary, Tat Conoju, La Aurora Preferido Red and Gold Tubo, and Liga Privada #9 and T52

Rhamlin

Shaun.Harrison87:
Rhamlin:
My biggest let down has been any ISOM that I have tried. Admittedly I've only had 5 but I always expected more out of them.
Which ones did you have? Are you 100% sure they were authentic?

Monte Cristo's and yeah I'm pretty sure they were real. A friend picked them up in Jamaica from a cigar shop that was inside a 5 star hotel lobby. I mean they were good but not great. And a couple had horrible burn issues that just totally ruined it for me.

Shaun.Harrison87

Rhamlin:
Shaun.Harrison87:
Rhamlin:
My biggest let down has been any ISOM that I have tried. Admittedly I've only had 5 but I always expected more out of them.
Which ones did you have? Are you 100% sure they were authentic?
Monte Cristo's and yeah I'm pretty sure they were real. A friend picked them up in Jamaica from a cigar shop that was inside a 5 star hotel lobby. I mean they were good but not great. And a couple had horrible burn issues that just totally ruined it for me.

I have had a couple with some burn issues, CCs seems more suspect than NCs to do that if they aren't rested for a few years to help balance them out. I haven't had many Monte #2s, but the 2 I had were really good, one was an 07 and the other an 09.

puffmaster

Viaje Friends and family 2012 and also agree that the padron 26 is over rated.

Roberto99

Rhamlin:
Shaun.Harrison87:
Rhamlin:
My biggest let down has been any ISOM that I have tried. Admittedly I've only had 5 but I always expected more out of them.
Which ones did you have? Are you 100% sure they were authentic?
Monte Cristo's and yeah I'm pretty sure they were real. A friend picked them up in Jamaica from a cigar shop that was inside a 5 star hotel lobby. I mean they were good but not great. And a couple had horrible burn issues that just totally ruined it for me.

Ricky, my friend... If you are being serious, that pretty much means they were not real. There isn't an LCDH in Jamaica and from my own experience I don't believe any real cc's can be found there. I purchased from a 5 star hotel in Jamaica and they were most definitely not real.

edelrionyc

San Lotano Oval just didn't cut it for me.....

stephen_hannibal

Most things RP... excluding, of all things, the Connecticut.
Almost every Tat... they have this harshness to them that doesn't fit my palate.

I'm sure there's more but I can't recall.

twistedstem

smoked an rp decade i had been sitting on for a while.had high expectations for it.was dissapointed.wasnt bad just not what i was hoping for

jgibv

ShotgunJohn:
I was let down when San Migel was dropped by AJ

^^^^THIS^^^^
+1

(FWIW - I remember reading somewhere that it was dropped because of a dispute with the name. Supposedly Gurkha had a trademark/copyright on that name prior to AJ releasing it.)

Vulchor

stephen_hannibal:
Most things RP... excluding, of all things, the Connecticut.
Almost every Tat... they have this harshness to them that doesn't fit my palate.

I'm sure there's more but I can't recall.

A big +1 on the Tat's

xmacro

Tatuajue Havana; was expecting more

brianetz1

this national championship game

Lee.mcglynn

I will also add the davidoff maduro toro...not at all why I though it would be!!

jliu

GoF maduro. why did I buy a box?!

Lee.mcglynn

jliu:
GoF maduro. why did I buy a box?!

Lmao any chance it will age well????? I got a few of them resting

jliu

Lee.mcglynn:
jliu:
GoF maduro. why did I buy a box?!
Lmao any chance it will age well????? I got a few of them resting

it better freakin age well. ok, I actually think it might. we'll see. if it doesn't i'll smoke it when I'm buzzed haha

jeep edson

that suxs jun. cause i also got a box cause the deal was to good. but if they suck the deal wasn't so good after all

Lee.mcglynn

jliu:
Lee.mcglynn:
jliu:
GoF maduro. why did I buy a box?!
Lmao any chance it will age well????? I got a few of them resting
it better freakin age well. ok, I actually think it might. we'll see. if it doesn't i'll smoke it when I'm buzzed haha

Lol yup then follow with a padron!!!!!

ENFIDL

jliu:
GoF maduro. why did I buy a box?!

So that when I come steal your coolers like a ninja in the night I can have them muahahahahahaha

Heavy

raisindot:
Gran Habano Vintage 2002: Bought 20 of these on a whim. Quite mediocre. Trying to get rid of 'em.

Robusto or churchill? If robusto, I would be interested in taking a few off your hands. Shoot me a PM and let me know if you're interested in a trade and what you might be interested in.

I must admit I've been on a bit of a smoking hiatus and would need to take an inventory on what I have available, but I definitely have a pretty decent assortment of sticks, particularly in the budget-premium range like the GH2002.

jliu

ENFIDL:
jliu:
GoF maduro. why did I buy a box?!
So that when I come steal your coolers like a ninja in the night I can have them muahahahahahaha

Oh no need. I have your addy now. Ill send them to you

pelirrojo

I quite enjoyed the CAO Gold. The CAO Gold Maduro was not good at all. I was pretty let down to say the least.

jgibv

jgibv:
ShotgunJohn:
I was let down when San Migel was dropped by AJ
^^^^THIS^^^^
+1

(FWIW - I remember reading somewhere that it was dropped because of a dispute with the name. Supposedly Gurkha had a trademark/copyright on that name prior to AJ releasing it.)

BUMP

Just spotted on another site, rebranded as "Gurkha San Miguel" --- cigar and bands look exact same as before.

Ken Light

jgibv:
jgibv:
ShotgunJohn:
I was let down when San Migel was dropped by AJ
^^^^THIS^^^^
+1

(FWIW - I remember reading somewhere that it was dropped because of a dispute with the name. Supposedly Gurkha had a trademark/copyright on that name prior to AJ releasing it.)
BUMP

Just spotted on another site, rebranded as "Gurkha San Miguel" --- cigar and bands look exact same as before.

Found this as well. Don't know if it's just ad hype or reality, but the video implied this might be a limited release.

jgibv

Ken Light:
jgibv:
jgibv:
ShotgunJohn:
I was let down when San Migel was dropped by AJ
^^^^THIS^^^^
+1

(FWIW - I remember reading somewhere that it was dropped because of a dispute with the name. Supposedly Gurkha had a trademark/copyright on that name prior to AJ releasing it.)
BUMP

Just spotted on another site, rebranded as "Gurkha San Miguel" --- cigar and bands look exact same as before.
Found this as well. Don't know if it's just ad hype or reality, but the video implied this might be a limited release.

FWIW:
These were originally blended and released by AJ back in 2010 (? I think). But in early 2012 they were "discontinued" and listed as "sold out" on all the retailer's websites. And from what I remember, nobody officially seemed to know why.
But about that time, I remember reading somewhere (not sure if it was an official article or just speculation on a forum) that there was supposedly a trademark/copyright dispute with Gurkha over the name "San Miguel". Something like Gurkha owned the name first and they weren't too pleased about AJ using it....

Now, I'm just speculating on this next part, about them being limited release.....

But seeing as they're rebranded as Gurkha San Miguel, I'd guess the trademark/copyright issue was true, and there was still inventory but it couldn't be sold due to the naming dispute.
Therefore I'd assume that original naming dispute has since been resolved since they're for sale again.
The wrapper and bands on these look absolutely identical to the "original" San Miguel's made by AJ. The only difference I can tell is the Gurkha name thrown on front in the ad.

So as far as limited release....IDK, if this was extra inventory, then perhaps once it's gone, it's gone for good?
Or maybe, if Gurkha now owns the name - it will no longer be blended by AJ. And Gurkha's going to re-do the blend and re-release it as a different San Miguel?
Your guess is as good as mine as to why these are limited ...
But I guess with them being rebranded as Gurkha, I'm not going to hold my breath and expect the blend to stay the same for long, ya know?

(And sorry for completely hijacking your thread, Rain. I'll *try to* shut up about San Miguel now)

KCW

Cuban Cigars. I really don't know what I expected but, when I had my first real cuban I was "Let Down". Not that it was bad or anything. I think I just expected it to blow me away. I guess I expected it to be the best cigar I ever had (the forbidden fruit thing). It wasn't.

Bobbo2009

For me it would have to be a AF Hemingway Short Story. I had a Hemingway of a different size a couple of years ago at a B&M that I sat down at. I really like smaller ring or gauge sticks and I loved reading about the short story. All of the great reviews it got. I just had to try one. I finally got one from one of the great BOTL's here and lite it up a month or so ago. Boy was I bummed. I lost my notes on it but it was nowhere as good as I thought it would be. Actually it wasn't good at all. I might go out and get another one one of these days, but I got plenty to keep me busy from my secret santa (thanks kuzi) for now.

ENFIDL

jliu:
ENFIDL:
jliu:
GoF maduro. why did I buy a box?!
So that when I come steal your coolers like a ninja in the night I can have them muahahahahahaha
Oh no need. I have your addy now. Ill send them to you

In the words of the late great colonel sanders I'm too drunk to taste this chicken